The Orange Box on Xbox 360: You Can't Go Wrong
The Orange Box put five Valve games on one disc: Half-Life 2, Half-Life 2: Episode One, Half-Life 2: Episode Two, Portal and Team Fortress 2. It came out on PC, Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3, and the console versions are not the same.

The Orange Box on Xbox 360 is a solid 9, and Samuel's take is simple: you can't go wrong. Everything was good. On PS3, it's a different story. It's not THAT bad, but it looks that bad.
What's in the box
Valve released The Orange Box in 2007, and it's one of the best deals in gaming. One disc gets you Half-Life 2, Episode One and Episode Two, the whole Combine story from City 17 to White Forest, plus Portal, the puzzle game with GLaDOS and the portal gun, plus Team Fortress 2, the class-based multiplayer shooter with nine classes.
That's three stories, a puzzle game and a multiplayer game that people are still playing years later. Samuel already gives Half-Life 2 and its episodes a 10 on their own.
On Xbox 360
On 360, you can't go wrong. Everything was good: the games ran well, they looked good, and Xbox Live made playing Team Fortress 2 online easy. As far as Samuel knows, you didn't need an EA account to play it either. The 360 version is also still playable on newer Xbox consoles through backward compatibility.
One complaint, though it doesn't count against the score: in February 2023, the digital version was pulled from the Xbox 360 store, along with Left 4 Dead and Left 4 Dead 2. Samuel figures it's probably licensing or something. The disc still works, including on newer Xbox consoles.
On PS3
The PS3 version is where it falls short. Valve made and put out the 360 version itself, but the PS3 version was ported by EA's UK studio and published by EA, and it shows. It's not THAT bad, but it looks that bad: the graphics are very blurry and the frame rate is worse, so the same games that run fine on 360 feel rough on PS3. Across every game on the disc, it's lowkey all a bit dark, and Half-Life 2 gets it the worst.
It also has no trophies, which Samuel says isn't the worst part, but it doesn't help. And as far as he can tell, the PS3 version needs an EA account to play, which is an extra hoop the 360 version doesn't make you jump through.
To be fair, the PS3 was legit trying its best, and Samuel respects Valve and Sony's dedication to getting these games on the console at all.
Online
On 360, the online side is dying, mostly in Team Fortress 2, where finding a full lobby is getting harder. On PS3, it's already gone. EA shut down the PS3 Team Fortress 2 servers for good on March 28, 2023, more than 15 years after launch.
The verdict
On Xbox 360, The Orange Box is five great games on one disc, and you can't go wrong. On PS3, it's not that bad, but the blurry graphics, worse frames, no trophies and the EA account hold it back. Get it on 360. A solid 9.